Yep Erik, the Zune isn't to many what the iPod is, but how in the hell does that make the Zune (Gen 1 or 2) one of the 10 Worst Gadgets of 2007. Sure, I am defending my device of choice, but your labeling the Zune the #8 worst Gadget of 2007 shows me you are clueless. No, the Zune to most doesn't compare to the iPod Touch, but sir... do some research, it more than competes with the iPod Classic 80 (The Zune 80s competition since you probably didn't know that). In fact some publications have the Zune 80 edging out the iPod Classic 80. Looks to me like you have an agenda Erik.
8. Microsoft Zune | $150 to $250
To take on the iPod, Apple's sleek little Goliath with record-breaking sales and a spot in the Museum of Modern Art's permanent collection, Microsoft last year unveiled the Zune: a larger, heavier, equally-expensive device. What did it have that the iPod didn't? The ability to temporarily share songs with others Zunes. Of course, this interesting feature was crippled by a three-play or three-day expiration (whichever came first). Microsoft also had the questionable logic of offering the brick-shaped device in brown. Quite simply, instead of killing the iPod, the Zune barely made a whimper when it was introduced.
Cut to this year. Apple has revamped their entire iPod line, shrinking their already-tiny Nanos and adding the iPhone's multitouch interface to a non-phone media player. So how does Microsoft respond? By matching the size and feature set of the previous year's iPods and not even attempting to compete on price (the updated Zunes cost pretty much exactly the same as the new iPods). It's almost as if Microsoft didn't anticipate Apple making a single update or change to their constantly evolving line of players.
Oh, by the way... the LG Chocolate is one of most popular, well regarded feature phones on the Verizon Network...
Zune Videos Zune Tutorials Zune Software Zune Social Zune Rumors Zune Resources Zune Phone Zune Originals Zune Music Zune Mods Zune Marketing Zune Limited Edition Zune Launch Zune Hardware Zune Guides Zune Flash 4/8 Zune Firmware Zune Features Zune Events Zune Deals Zune Commercials Zune Commentary Zune Cases Zune Backgrounds Zune Accessories Zune 80 Zune 30 Site Items Reviews Off Topic Important Got Zune Week in Review Got Zune Poll Got Zune Contests Docks Cases After Market Accessories
11 Responses for "Idiot of the Day : Erik Sofge of Popular Mechanics"
Can someone please get this guy a clue. He really needs the help. Â
How on earth does he get off saying the zune is not competing with the ipod classic, it is probably the biggest competitor to the ipod out there. Also yeah the zune 30 was alot bigger but it still has a screen twice the size of an ipod. What was he thinking when he said the zune 80 doesn’t compete with the ipod classic, plus I think Microsoft has made a better player than Apple in a fraction of the time
Has this jerk ever even used a zune, cause he’s got something really wrong with his head!!!!!!!!
What’s this guy doing in tech, some people can’t handle change.
he’s a macfanboy all the way.
I agree, makes you wonder if he actually even tested one.Â
He definitely needs a clue. Maybe we should all chip in and buy him one.
To many the Zune30 wasn’t the tiny tech toy everyone was looking for, but it is a high quality player with an excellent screen. It also includes FM radio, which Apple is too good to include. Plus, the Zune80 is beating the iPod classic on many tech sites.
As for his other worst of ‘07, I also have to make an exception for Pleo. Its the most advanced robot pet around, and it looks like it could be a lot of fun. How can you say something is terrible, when you have never even used it. It might not be your thing, but don’t knock it.
After reading what I wrote here, I feel bad for calling this guy an idiot. Maybe I shouldn’t be so harsh.
No, he is an idiot!
"shrinking their already-tiny Nanos"
WHAT!!!!!!!! They made them fat and ugly, they didn’t shrink them.
"It’s almost as if Microsoft didn’t anticipate Apple making a single update or change to their constantly evolving line of players."
has this guy seen the iPod "basically the same device we’ve had for 3 years, we just changed the casing and made the firmware suck more" Classic?
No Chris, you’re on point. This guy must be trying to score points with apple, two bad he pick the wrong zune.
That’s far past ridiculous. All of the comments on that review are in agreement that it’s bias at it’s worst. Oh well. Freedom of speech also means freedom of idiocy. =P
It’s OK Chris, don’t worry about it.
Considering that this is GotZUNE.com, not too many people are gonna get mad at you for callin him an idiot.
Anyways, this guy really needs to do a tad more research before listing off such ridiculous things.
*Smacks him on the head*
this is me rolling my eyes.
the prices are the same and the there are improvements. And I think the flash player shape is way nicer than the new nano.
But hey he put the iPhone on the list too. So I guess he can’t be that biased.
Leave a reply